Pricing


Ordering

When it comes to personal occasion or special event cake, we prefer to have 3 week notice for an order. There is some flexibility depending on the current week’s workload, so feel free to call us even if you have last minute order. For wedding cakes, it is suggested to be on our books two months before your event.

Pricing will vary depending on cake decoration and cake filling. Prices will go up for more elaborate designs and decorations. We have $150 minimum on all our orders.

Deposit

We require $100 non-refundable deposit for wedding cakes to reserve your wedding date and the remaining balance is due 14 days before the event date. For all other cakes, 50% non-refundable deposit is required.

Delivery

We offer free delivery within 5 miles of South Milwaukee on your cake order. Delivery is figured at $0.60 per mile outside of 5mile radius both ways.

Pick ups

Personal pick ups are acceptable and are at your own risk. We will not be responsible for delivery of your cake once it leaves the premises.

Tasting

We offer cake tasting for events with a guest count of 100 people and over. You can choose up to three cake and filling flavors from our flavor list. Because we bake all of our cakes to order, we will need at least two days notice for all tasting appointments. We charge $15 for our cake tasting for 2 guests, which is credited towards your cake purchase; each additional guest is $5. Payment is due when you schedule your appointment and is non-refundable. 

Wedding Cakes

Our wedding cake prices start at $4.00 per serving. Couples ordering their Wedding Cake with us that feed 100 people and more receive a free delivery for first 20 miles.

For appointment, please call 262-327-4745 or email us at info@myfantasycake.com

Novelty Cakes

The base price for our custom cakes starts at $4.00 per serving with final price being dependent on total number of people served and the intricacy of the design.

Topsy Turvy and Custom 3D cakes

Pricing for custom sculpted and topsy turvy cakes is based on the complexity of design and the number of people being served. The price for our sculpted cakes and topsy turvy starts at $4.85 per serving. Minimum cake price is $180

Mini Cakes

Mini cakes are gourmet single serving cakes that are decorated and served to guests individually. Mini cakes are priced at the high decorative design point, due to the use of increased amount of materials, labor, decorating skills and time necessary to create individually decorated cake for each guest. Mini cakes come in one, two or three tier square or round shapes. One tier mini cakes starts at $7 per serving/cake, and are appropriate for small events of 100 guests or less. Two and three tier mini cakes are priced at high end of the range - prices start at $10 per cake - and are appropriate for very small events of 50 guests or less. Not all cake flavors work well with mini cakes. Mini cakes may be filled with most of our fillings.

Cupcakes

Cupcakes start at $3.00 each, and are sold in groups of 24 – 1 flavor per 24, or 12 if you are ordering a cake too. Prices increase from there, based on the intricacy of the design. Gourmet Cupcakes start at $3.50 each. Check some of our cupcake flavors in our Cupcake Galler

Cupcake Bouquet

Cupcake Bouquet is one of the most popular edible gifts! We offer different designs and sizes for cupcake bouquets.

Cupcakes in a pot – 6 cupcakes in custom designed cupcake pot. Starting at $30.

Small Cupcake Bouquet – 14 cupcakes. Starting at $60

Large Cupcake Bouquet – 24 cupcakes. Starting at $90

Push Pop Cakes

Our new take on the cake - Push-Pop Cakes - are layers of our delicious cake and frosting - just like your favorite cake - in an easy to eat, no mess push-pop container.

Push-Pops start at $3 each, and are sold in groups of 24 – 1 flavor per 24.

Cake Pops

Basic Cake Pops start at $2.50 each
   *Drizzle and sprinkles only
Custom Cake Pops start at - $3.50 each*
   *Special designs, (colors, flowers, hearts, etc) for special occasion.
Custom Shaped Cake Pops start at $5.00 each*
    *hearts, flowers, stars, bride & groom, baby & etc

There is a minimum order of 2 dozen (24) cake pops.  This includes one cake flavor.  Orders over 60 cake pops may include two cake flavors.  Orders over 150 cake pops may include three cake flavors.  For 200+ you may choose up to four flavors.

Dessert Tables

Designed dessert tables are becoming really popular and customized sweets are made to each client’s needs. You can choose one of our premade packages or you can customize your own dessert table. Our minimum order for a custom design table is $150 and includes:

 

 

 

 -        12 Cupcakes

-         12 Chocolate Covered Strawberries 

-         12 Push pops

-         12 Cookies

$250 package includes:

-         24 Cupcakes                                          

-         24 Push pops

-         12 cake pops                                

-         12 Cookies

-         12 Cheesecake shooters                          

-         12 Chocolate Covered Strawberries